Tuesday, 3 July 2018

Reconciliation with Councillor Cilevitz Sought for Week Ending 2018-07-07

Revision history:

  • 20180705T2150Z/version 3.0.0: Kmo updated Sectoin 2, to document the situation as at UTC=20180705T2150Z. 
  • 20180704T2132Z/version 2.0.0: Kmo updated Section 2, to document the situation as at UTC=
  • 20180704T0203Z/version 1.0.1: Kmo corrected an unfortunate typo (changing the erroneous "2017-07-03" in the "NOW THEREFORE" paragraph to the correct "2018-07-03", and retransmitting his e-mail to clerks@richmondhill.ca, again with cc to 920@yrp.ca).
  • 20180703T2008Z/version 1.0.0: Kmo, having just e-mailed clerks@richmondhill.ca with cc to 920@yrp.ca, uploaded a complete section "1." , with stubs for the remaining sections.


1. Letter to Clerks in Town of Richmond Hill, with Also General blogspot Dissemination

Coordinated Universal Time (= UTC = EST+5 = EDT+4): 20180703T200418Z



Toomas Karmo = Toomas.Karmo@gmail.com 

(with effect from 2018-07-01
residing  at 86 Crosby Avenue, Richmond Hill L4C 2R2; 

cellphone is unchanged, continuing to be 647-267-9566)  

RE: requesting Clerks' assistance w/Cnclr K.Cilevitz casework 


A. Preliminary Remark

Although I am writing on a rather small municipal matter, I nevertheless find it convenient to use here the "WHEREAS...AND WHEREAS" and "NOW THEREFORE" format sometimes used in large municipal matters. 

B. The Body of My Letter

  • Councillor Cilevitz and I agree on the importance of free public speech

  • the Town and I jointly reinforced free-speech precedents on 2014-12-01 (MON), when I attended, unimpeded, and with plainclothes police protection, the social portion of the Town Council inaugural meeting, with flyers and placard in protest against the impending destruction of 32 out of the total 76.5 David Dunlap Observatory and Park greenspace hectares (therein opposing the pro-subdivision position of Councillor Cilevitz)

  • I have been placed under some personal-communications restrictions in a 2014 out-of-court settlement with Karen Cilevitz, in 2014 casework detailed at my sites http://www.karen-vs-toomas-blog.ca/ and http://www.karen-vs-toomas-legaldocs.ca/

  • my two principal previous efforts, in the 2016 summer and the 2018 spring, at effecting a personal reconciliation with Councillor Cilevitz have been unsuccessful

  • Councillor Cilevitz is now the subject of a public dispute, or public controversy, involving local music-industry figures Mr Matthew Bergman and Ms Steffi Goodfield

  • the controversy offers a fresh opportunity for a reconciliation between Councillor Cilevitz and me, as I alert the public to deficiencies in some media coverage of the dispute or controversy

  • no out-of-court settlement - and in particular, not the 2014 out-of-court settlement between Councillor Cilevitz and me, on whose specific terms I herewith make no commentary - can undercut citizens' rights to civic participation, including the right to interview Councillors of their municipalities

  • on 2018-06-20 I had a 1h22m phone chat with Mr Matthew Bergman, in which he has put his side of the case to me

  • it is ethically correct to balance this 2018-06-20 chat with Mr Bergman by having a corresponding chat with Councillor Cilevitz, in which she puts her side of the case to me, and in so doing additionally explores with me the possibilities of a personal reconciliation between her and me

  • Councillor Cilevitz declared her willingness to chat with the public on the controversy, in her Facebook posting of 2018-05-31 (using for her declaration the wording "Should anyone have any questions or concerns regarding this matter, I invite you to contact me personally to have that discussion")

  • I now seek a chat of at least 5 minutes' duration, face to face, in the evening (at any time from 5:00 p.m. onward) of 2018-07-05 (THU), in the morning or afternoon or evening of 2018-07-06 (FRI), or in the morning of 2018-07-07 (SAT), with permission to operate my voice recorder, and with permission to use my voice recording in any way that may at any time seem appropriate to me - letting Councillor Cilevitz tell her side of the story in any way she pleases, to balance the account I received from Mr Bergman in our 2018-06-20 1h22m phone chat

  • I additionally seek in our envisaged chat to put the following four questions to Councillor Cilevitz:

    (1) Has she directed the Richmond Hill bylaw enforcement authorities to action in respect of any person or business connected with the entertainment or hospitality industry?

    (2) Is she willing to affirm to me privately my civic right to attend her "Ward 5 Music Festival" municipal event of 2018-07-07 (SAT) in Mount Pleasant Park, and to affirm to me privately my civic right in the course of my attendance to carry chest and back placards worded "COMMENT ABOUT MEDIA", and to affirm to me privately my civic right in the course of my attendance to hand out flyers headed "COMMENT ABOUT MEDIA" bearing the approximate text of the "APPENDIX" to this e-mail?

    (3) Can Councillor Cilevitz suggest any improvements in the draft text shown in my "APPENDIX"?

    (4) Does Councillor Cilevitz, while recognizing that there can legally be no ban on communications between the two of us in her Town-official capacity, now join me in an additional willingness to lift the ban on communications in her private-citizen capacity, thereby effecting a personal reconciliation between us? 

I respectfully ask Clerks to convey the substance of this letter in some way or other to Councillor Cilevitz (for example, by referring her in e-mail to my 2018-07-03
blogspot posting, which displays the text of this same e-mail; or by referring her through a phone call to my 2018-07-03 blogspot posting; or by directly forwarding this e-mail to her),and to confirm for me in a short e-mail that they have in some way or other conveyed the substance to her.

C. Concluding Remark

It would be appropriate for me to receive a response by the late afternoon of 2018-07-04 (WED), either from Clerks or directly from Councillor Cilevitz, in one of the following three logically possible forms: 

  1. No; contrary to your own professed belief, Dr Karmo, Councillor Cilevitz is under no obligation to grant an interview to you, and indeed declines to grant an interview. The legal reasoning supporting the Town's finding of "no obligation" (Councillor Cilevitz's municipal Oath of Office and the Town's municipal Code of Conduct notwithstanding) is the following: [[[[some reasoning here]]]]
  2. Sorry; nobody at the Town can transmit a reply to you by the late afternoon of 2018-07-04 (WED). Please anticipate a somewhat delayed response, on or before [[[[date here]]]]. 
  3. Yes, short interview granted: please attend at [[[[time here]]]], at [[[[place]]]]. 

(signed) TK

APPENDIX: Draft of Flyer for Public Distribution 2018-07-07

It is my civic duty to alert the public to deficiencies in the media coverage of a dispute (a controversy) involving Councillor Karen Cilevitz. 

(1) The Richmond Hill Liberal, at  https://www.yorkregion.com/news-story/8679645-richmond-hill-councillor-karen-cilevitz-demands-apology-retraction/ (dateline 2018-06-19, headline "Richmond Hill councillor Karen Cilevitz demands apology, retraction: Thornhill musician says councillor harassed vulnerable people", byline "Kim Zarzour") errs in discussing previous coverage. The most significant error is the Liberal's failure to supply readers, in the course of its discussion of previous coverage, with a link to the most pertinent piece of previous coverage - namely, to the YouTube (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YBzt5jfE3zY) upload of 2018-06-08, by YouTube user "Rebel Media", under headline "Ward 5 Councillor's 'threats' to shut down musical acts baffles residents". The omission is significant because this particular coverage, unlike other coverage to which the Liberal does refer, explores by-law enforcement, raising a question of abuse of municipal power (to which the Councillor replies, in her remarks to the reporter, that there has been no abuse). As of early July, at UTC=20180703T173559Z, the "Rebel Media" YouTube upload had gained the surprisingly large total of 18,240 views.

(2) Councillor Cilevitz's Facebook page, https://www.facebook.com/karencilevitz/, has been censored by someone, with incoming comments critical of the Councillor systematically, again and again, deleted soon after the server began displaying them (as I myself document, with screenshots, at http://toomaskarmo.blogspot.com/2018/06/public-service-posting-facebook.html (comment of 2018-06-05, headed "PUBLIC-SERVICE POSTING: Facebook operations of Town Councillor Karen Cilevitz")).

An unfettered press is one of the bulwarks of Ontario's liberties. 


Toomas Karmo ((((Toomas.Karmo@gmail.com; 647-267-9566; I perform my ethical duty to disclose personals, by citing the my two pertinent Web sites (illuminating Cilevitz 2014 legals): http://www.karen-vs-toomas-blog.ca/, http://www.karen-vs-toomas-legaldocs.ca/))))


2. Response from Councillor Cilevitz's Side

[Situation reports are arranged in reverse chronological order, i.e., with most recent report at the beginning rather than at the end.]

(2) Situation as at UTC=20180705T215000Z:

Mail received from an official at Clerks, from UTC=20180705T1701Z, indicating that Clerks communicated my case to Councillor Cilevitz 2018-07-04 (WED), and that this official is ((QUOTE)) in the process of following-up((/QUOTE)) on my e-mail, and that this official will communicate an update to me upon receiving ((QUOTE))a reply from the Councillor((/QUOTE)).

I replied to this official as follows, copying also Mayor and Council and Sergeant Chris Palmer:

Coordinated Universal Time (= UTC = EST+5 = EDT+4): 20180704T215000Z

Dear ((REDACTED WHAT="name of official")),
with cc Mayor and Council, and Sergeant Chris Palmer,
and with posting to http://toomaskarmo.blogspot.com with your name redacted:

Thanks very much. I am quite sure you have now done all that is presently in your power. I am now **NOT** left with any reason for distrusting Clerks, and a fortiori am **NOT** left with any reason for filing a complaint at the Ombudsman's office.

As you work on Councillor Cilevitz's file, the following fresh points may be of some help:

(a) I have today had a reasonably detailed chat, to a length of around 00h20m or 00h30m, with an individual, "ABCD", who has at least some inside knowledge of the Councillor Cilevitz file, and who has at least some level of personal sympathy for Councillor Cilevitz. On the strength of ABCD's various pieces of advice to me, I am now not at all certain that I should be distributing flyers at the 2018-07-07 (SAT) Ward 5 municipal event. My reasoning is now that in distributing flyers, I might be making myself the unwitting pawn of a faction in  Richmond Hill which wishes Councillor Cilevitz misfortune, and which has in ABCD's private estimation additionally shown some tendency toward intemperate action.

(b) In view of today's reasonably detailed chat with ABCD, it becomes all the more important for me to have an interview with Councillor Cilevitz, with my voice recorder running.  The Councillor may well have some argument for me establishing that my envisaged 2018-07-07 distribution of flyers would be unwise, as tending to assist an intemperate faction in our community without significantly tending to improve our community newspaper. Until I have such an interview, I cannot decide confidently either for or against flyer distribution.

My monitoring of e-mails tomorrow, 2018-07-06 (FRI), may be unreliable, as I continue working on a move from 406 Centre Street East (L4C 1B7) to 86 Crosby Avenue (L4C 2R2). On the other hand, I **COULD** interrupt my work on the move for 40, 80, or 150 minutes to attend to something as important as an interview with the Councillor. It would therefore be advisable for the Councillor or you to phone me as appropriate, on my usual number (647-267-9566), in place of relying on e-mail. You could always send me an e-mail also, for the formal record, secure in the assurance that I would be able to read it by 2018-07-09 (MON), perhaps without being able to read it as early as 2018-07-06 (FRI).


Toomas Karmo

(1) Situation as at UTC=20180704T211412Z:

Transmitted following to Mayor and Council, as
officemayor@richmondhill.ca, vito.spatafora@richmondhill.ca, brenda.hogg@richmondhill.ca, greg@gregberos.com, tom.muench@richmondhill.ca, castro.liu@richmondhill.ca, david.west@richmondhill.ca, karen.cilevitz@richmondhill.ca, godwin.chan@richmondhill.ca, 

with cc both to clerks@richmondhill.ca and to 920@yrp.ca:

Coordinated Universal Time (= UTC = EST+5 = EDT+4): 20180704T211412Z

Dear Members of Town Council, with Office of Mayor
(and with cc both to Clerks and to YRP Sergeant Chris Palmer):

In trying to effect a reconciliation with Councillor Karen Cilevitz,
I sent important e-mail on 2018-07-03 (TUE) to Clerks,
making my e-mail also publicly viewable at http://toomaskarmo.blogspot.com
(in a posting of 2018-07-03, headed "Reconciliation with Councillor Cilevitz
Sought for Week Ending 2018-07-07". To my surprise, Clerks have
not responded to my mail, even though they know it is their
formal duty to respond, and even though they know I have had
success in the past at the Ontario Ombudsman's office, in
resolving casework in which Clerks appeared negligent in
correspondence formalities. I have asked Clerks to respond
on 2018-07-05 (THU).

Any suggestions or advice from any of you would now be
useful, as I seek to avoid an escalation to Ombudsman
on 2018-07-06 (FRI).


Toomas Karmo

---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Toomas Karmo <toomas.karmo@gmail.com>
Date: Wed, Jul 4, 2018 at 5:13 PM
Subject: Clerks: seeking yr response to my mailing of 2018-07-03 (TUE)
To: clerks <clerks@richmondhill.ca>
Cc: "Toomas.Karmo" <Toomas.Karmo@gmail.com>

Coordinated Universal Time (= UTC = EST+5 = EDT+4): 20180704T210544Z

Dear Clerks,

I e-mailed you twice yesterday. 2018-07-03 (TUE)  on the same matter,
once in the afternoon and once in the evening.  The second mailing,
copied below, corrected a typo in the first mailing.

It is now just after 5:00 p.m., and to my surprise I have received no
response to yesterday's e-mails. Could you respond, please, at some
point on 2018-07-05 (THU)? I will be away from my computer for part of
that day, but will nevertheless be able to deal with correspondence
intermittently - being, further, able to deal with incoming
correspondence thoroughly and with full concentration toward the end
of the day, perhaps around 5:00 p.m. or 6:00 p.m.

Sincerely, anxiously,

Toomas Karmo
647-267-9566; new municipal address, as of 2018-07-01 = 86 Crosby
Avenue, Richmond Hill L4C 2R2

((SNIP WHAT="copy of text from my 2018-07-03 e-mail submission to Clerks")) 

3. My Impressions upon Attending Councillor Cilevitz's 2018-07-07 Municipal Event

[This section to be filled in a few hours after the end of Councillor Cilevitz's 2018-07-07 Mount Pleasant Park "Ward 5 Music Festival" municipal event.]

[This is the end of the current blogspot posting.]

Sunday, 10 June 2018

The "DDO&P Conflict", 2007-09-10 to 2018-06-09

Clockwise from lower right: (1) the homebrew Yagi antenna which I am to be donating to YLab at DDO, for possible use in meteor radio observations (a tape measure, extended to a length of one metre, runs parallel to the boom, and a metre stick is partially visible to the right, running perpendicular to the boom); (2) the front panel of the Westinghouse 7-valve receiver which I am to be donating to YLab, along with a detail from its back panel; (3) the DDO 1.88-metre telescope, as I photographed it on 2018-06-09 (with the 1930s Grubb-and-Parsons fabricator plaque partly visible at the bottom edge of the photo, on the south side of the south pier); (4) the 1.88-metre telescope control room, as a reminder of departed glories, from my visit of 2018-06-09  (although the joystick, for guiding starlight down the spectrograph slit, can be seen to the left of the obsolete monitor, the spectrograph controller electronics have now been dismounted from the telescope). May we hope some day, perhaps through an infusion of something like National Research Council funds, for a revival of DDO spectroscopy? - As is usual in blogspot publishing, the image can be enlarged with a left mouse-click.

Quality assessment:

On the 5-point scale current in Estonia, and surely in nearby nations, and familiar to observers of the academic arrangements of the late, unlamented, Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (applying the easy and lax standards Kmo deploys in his grubby imaginary "Aleksandr Stepanovitsh Popovi nimeline sangarliku raadio instituut" (the "Alexandr Stepanovitch Popov Institute of Heroic Radio") and his  grubby imaginary "Nikolai Ivanovitsh Lobatshevski nimeline sotsalitsliku matemaatika instituut" (the "Nicolai Ivanovich Lobachevsky Institute of Socialist Mathematics") - where, on the lax and easy grading philosophy of the twin Institutes, 1/5 is "epic fail", 2/5 is "failure not so disastrous as to be epic", 3/5 is "mediocre pass", 4/5 is "good", and 5/5 is "excellent"): 4/5. Justification: Kmo found the time to develop the essential points to reasonable length.

Revision history:
All times in these blog "revision histories" are stated in UTC (Universal Coordinated Time/ Temps Universel Coordoné,  a precisification of the old GMT, or "Greenwich Mean Time"), in the ISO-prescribed YYYYMMDDThhmmZ timestamping format. UTC currently leads Toronto civil time by 4 hours (with Toronto now on summer time) and currently lags Tallinn civil time by 2 hours (with Tallinn currently still on winter time). 
  • 20180611T2142Z/version 2.2.0: Kmo added a potentially significant point, that RASC has in the past formed a contractual relationship with DDO developer Corsica. (It is this, and not the mere silence of RASC as a corporate entity, at the CRB and OMB hearings, that justifies Kmo in representing RASC as tacitly dissenting from his own conservationist position.) - Kmo reserved the right to make further tiny, nonsubstantive, purely cosmetic, tweaks over the coming 48 hours, as here-undocumented versions 2.2.1, 2.2.2, 2.2.3, ... .
  • 20180611T2136Z/version 2.1.0: Kmo made a correction in his criticism of RASC (fortunately managing to get this in before anyone contacted him): although RASC has not to his knowledge taken an official conservationist position, for instance by becoming a "Party" at the 2009 Conservation Review Board hearing or the 2012 and 2014 Ontario Municipal Board hearings, nevertheless individual RASC members have communicated conservationist positions to authorities, acting in their private capacity. - Kmo reserved  the right to make further tiny, nonsubstantive, purely cosmetic, tweaks over the coming 48 hours, as here-undocumented versions 2.1.1, 2.1.2, 2.1.3, ... .
  • 20180611T1430Z/version 2.0.0: Kmo finished converting his point-form outline into full-sentences  prose, and also added a graphic. He reserved the right to make further tiny, nonsubstantive, purely cosmetic, tweaks over the coming 48 hours, as here-undocumented versions 2.0.1, 2.0.2, 2.0.3, ... .
  • 20180611T0222Z/version 1.0.0: Kmo uploaded a reasonably polished point-form outline. He hoped to finish converting this into full-sentences prose at some point in the coming 14 hours.
[CAUTION: A bug in the blogger server-side software has in some past months shown a propensity to insert inappropriate whitespace at some points in some of my posted essays. If a screen seems to end in empty space, keep scrolling down. The end of the posting is not reached until the usual blogger "Posted by Toomas (Tom) Karmo at" appears. - The blogger software has also shown a propensity, at any rate when coupled with my erstwhile, out-of-date, Web-authoring uploading browser, to generate HTML that gets formatted in different ways on different downloading browsers. Some downloading browsers have sometimes perhaps not correctly read in the entirety of the "Cascading Style Sheets" (CSS) which on all ordinary Web servers control the browser placement of margins, sidebars, and the like. If you suspect CSS problems in your particular browser, be patient: it is probable that while some content has been shoved into some odd place (for instance, down to the bottom of your browser, where it ought to appear in the right-hand margin), all the server content has been pushed down into your browser in some place or other. - Finally, there may be blogger vagaries, outside my control, in font sizing or interlinear spacing or right-margin justification. - Anyone inclined to help with trouble-shooting, or to offer other kinds of technical advice, is welcome to write me via Toomas.Karmo@gmail.com.]

The Saturday which was 2018-06-09 proved notable for Canadian astronomy.

On Canadian soil sit three rather hefty ships in what I like to call "God's Navy" - the Mont Mégantic observatory in Québec, the Dominion Astrophysical Observatory on Vancouver Island, and the (beleaguered) David Dunlap Observatory in Ontario. By a coincidence, two of these three had historic celebrations on the day - DAO, as part of its centenary observances (in a proceeding advertised at https://thecentreoftheuniverse.net/a-centennial-celebration); and DDO, to mark the formal start of municipally directed public outreach, after the 1935-2008 tenure of the University of Toronto and the temporary 2009-through-2016-or-2017 arrangement between the Royal Astronomical Society of Canada (RASC; https://www.rasc.ca/) and a temporary DDO owner, subdivision developer Corsica.

I do continue to censure the federal, provincial, and municipal authorities for allowing 32 hectares out of our 77-hectare legacy to be sacrificed to Corsica. The happy Saturday was, however, less a day for bemoaning what had been lost than for celebrating progress on fully four DDO fronts - as regards (A) the municipality (https://www.richmondhill.ca/en/david-dunlap-observatory.aspx), (B) the "YLab" (http://www.ylab.ca) citizen-engineering makerspace, (C) RASC (for citizen science), and (D) the David Dunlap Observatory Defenders (DDOD, again for citizen science; http://www.ddod.ca/).


(A) It was constructive of Mayor David Barrow to begin his remarks by citing the aboriginal First Nations, as the ancient tenants of the DDO terrain.

It was additionally constructive of Mayor Barrow to have used - as perhaps the first significant municipal officer, for perhaps the first time in my hearing, from any municipal microphone - the fully correct legal terminology for the terrain, as laid out in Jessie Donalda Dunlap's 1930s Deed of Indenture: what we are herewith conserving (now, all will admit, with a mix of success and failure) is in the prescriptive language of Mrs Dunlap's Deed the "David Dunlap Observatory and Park".


(B) YLab opened their DDO Adminstration-Building rooms to the public, demonstrating how solid a base they have already established for "citizen-engineering" outreach. Presently at their disposal are at least two of the four big legacy DDO workshops. (In the decades leading up to the unhappy 2008 change in DDO ownership, the basement housed optics, metalworking, and woodworking. On the Administration Building upper level was a big electronics room, with a slate-topped table that eventually got removed, I presume during the University of Toronto's 2008 sale.)

YLab have already made a beginning in fabrication, deploying not only three 3-D printers, but also a laser cutter similar to the big laser cutter which I have myself viewed in Toronto's HackLab (https://hacklab.to/). Further, YLab have  made a beginning in amateur radio, notably by already, in so short a time, helping eight or so school pupils qualify with Industry Canada for their amateur-radio operating licences.

On the equipment side, I saw a couple of transceivers for HF (with appropriate power supplies), as well as a VHF-or-UHF handheld.

It was a "Eureka" moment to see YLab deploying a UHF Yagi antenna whose boom-mounted elements were judiciously cut from that most convenient of metals, a tape measure!

Also noteworthy in my visit to the DDO YLab rooms was an imposing AF signal generator, capable of high peak-to-peak voltage swings (if I recall accurately, on the order of tens of kilovolts). This hefty box had been donated from the surplus stocks of the University of Toronto Department of Physics.

Mindful of YLab's demonstrated technological solidity, I immediately entered into an agreement to donate to them two minor items from my own surplus stocks:

  • I am to be giving to YLab a Yagi antenna, with wooden boom, and with metal wiring on wooden crosspieces as its active element, its reflector, and its (sole) director. The antenna feeds into twin-lead. Its elements are cut for the FM-broadcast frequency of 90.7 MHz. A Toronto radio restorator, "XYZ", and I had a few years ago put this bulky thing together for investigating ionization trails of meteors, with a particular view to such showers as the Perseids. (Our method was simple: you feed the Yagi into your ordinary humble consumer-electronics FM rig, and then you try to establish that you are hearing - for just a few seconds in each fleeting instance - stations too far from Toronto to be plausibly received except through bounces off meteor ionization trails. XYZ and I did catch a few distant (USA) FM broadcasters at a time presumed specially rich in meteors. However, we did not embark on a properly systematic mluti-day, multi-week radio observing campaign, such as would now seem appropriate at DDO.)
  • I am to be giving YLab a Westinghouse 7-valve (7-"tube") AM-FM monaural 1950s or 1960s tabletop radio, with model specification H86nN7, for some value of n in the set {0, 1, 2, 3}. This set is in wooden cabinetry - with the exact, but to me unknown, value of n corresponding to what the old Westinghouse marketers were pleased to call, respectively, "traditional mahogany", "colonial maple", "contemporary walnut", "provincial fruitwood". I guess what I have to offer YLab is not "colonial maple", and so does not correspond to n = 1. But given some degree of imagination, and some accompanying mental vagueness regarding fine cabinetry, my set could conceivably be held to correspond to any one of n = 0, 2, 3. - The design is of a quality arguably occupying the boundary between an upmarket postwar kitchen radio and a downmarket postwar hi-fi radio. The dial does now need restringing, I suppose with something like fishing line now going into its interior pulley. Further, noise which has developed in the last few years suggests that at least one electrolytic capacitor is now failing. (I have had the set since rescuing it from York University garbage in 1989 or 1990 or 1991. It sounded fine until just two or three or so years ago.) - Once restored, this set might perhaps be a suitable companion for the just-mentioned Yagi, in the just-mentioned investigation of meteors. - Readers should note that YLab are interested in receiving still more valve receivers from the general public, as their team works to hone its skills in radio restoration. 
I may be making other minor donations also (I have yet to discuss this with YLab). I also may soon be proposing the loan of various bits of radio gear, notably including an RF signal generator and an antenna analyzer. There will, however, have to be a caveat: I would be obliged to make my loans for a short term only. In September, or thereabouts, it will on present plans be time for me to finish packing all my Canadian chattels for sea transport to Estonia.


(C) I engaged in fully happy diplomacy with RASC on 2018-06-09, with a correctly friendly level of understanding replacing previous tensions. I think it would now be fair to say that both sides in the dialogue tacitly agree to disagree on the destroyed 32 DDO&P hectares, in other words on the 14-new-street Corsica subdivision - with RASC, through their entering into a contractual relationship with property developer Corsica, and through various past silences (notably in the media, and at the 2009 Conservation Review Board, and at the 2012-through-2015 Ontario Municipal Board and Divisional Court), implicitly dissenting from my own conservationist position. - I do have to add here (a point which I partially neglected in my various versions of my essay until "version 2.1.0", at UTC=20180611T2136Z) that individual members of RASC, as opposed to RASC itself as a "legal person" speaking in its corporate name, have been explicitly supportive of conservation. I return to this point briefly below, first in connection with RASC's Dr Ralph Chou, and then in connection with RASC's Mr Eric Briggs. 

I was privileged to chat on the day with the national RASC President, Mr Colin Haig (he was visiting DDO from Hamilton, Ontario), and to learn of his own interest in amateur radio, particularly in UHF fabrication.

I was happy also to chat with Dr Ralph Chou of the RASC Toronto Centre, and to express to him my gratitude for his warm private thanks to me this past week, in respect both of my annual RASC Observer's Handbook work (cf my blogspot posting of 2018-01-01, under the heading "The Visually Brightest Stars (Fresh RASC Publishing Initiatives)") and of my DDO conservationist advocacy.

Further, I was happy to chat with Mr Eric Briggs, likewise prominent in the RASC Toronto Centre, after hearing his DDO podium remarks on the role RASC has played in the educational formation of Canadian astrophysicists. From those podium remarks, I picked up much that was new to me - for instance, that my sometime University of Toronto classmate Sara Seager (now with MIT, as an exoplanets authority; https://www.saraseager.com/) has RASC ties, and that such ties  have existed in the remote past also - as with, e.g., the still-remembered DDO meteorite specialist Dr Peter Millman (1906-1990; he left DDO in 1940, began war service in 1941, and later served with the Dominion Observatory and the National Research Council).
It was additionally instructive to learn from these podium remarks that DDO's second Director, Prof. Reynold Young (1886-1977), had promoted Canada's war effort through RASC, trying to recruit optics engineers from the nationwide RASC rank-and-file (which back in those days must have been replete with mirror-grinders).

And I think I did not know until hearing Mr Briggs that astronomy enthusiast David Dunlap himself (1863-1924) may have first come to know of RASC in a community-service context. Mr Briggs noted that both Mr Dunlap and RASC's own Allan Miller were members of the Board at the Toronto General Hospital, around 1918.

Further, it is from Mr Briggs's podium remarks that I gather, or at any rate am reminded after years of amnesia, how strong was the support of individual RASC members for the conservationist position at the 2009 Conservation Review Board. Mr Briggs stated that over half of the conservation-supporting letters received at the Board came from RASC individuals.

Mindful of the fresh diplomatic détente with RASC, I would now respectfully offer the following points, or queries:

  • There is a conceivable RASC synergy with the YLab team, who are emerging as a centre of radio expertise. Could not YLab help RASC continue an activity started at DDO by RASC a few years ago, namely the monitoring of radio flux from the Sun? 
  • As I put my perhaps three or four shelf-metres of DDO advocacy paperwork into archive order, for conveying this autumn to some such public authority as the Richmond Hill Public Library or the Archives of Ontario, might RASC be interested in offering some for-them-painless logistic help? I am willing to sort that mountain of paper in the tight confines of my upcoming final Canadian place of residence, and would be happy also to sort it within the pleasantly quiet (again somewhat tight) walls of the Local History Room at the Richmond Hill Public Library. But might it be possible to do the sorting within the wider walls of DDO, perhaps during business hours, under arrangement with the Town and in my capacity as a RASC member? I could if necessary supply my own computer equipment, chair, and (folding) table. In general, for archive work the more space one has to spread things out, in some deserted room with a generous vacant floor, the better. 
  • Should some effort now be made to produce a multi-author history of DDO, with part coming from me, and other parts from established historians within the ranks of RASC? RASC has established its historiographic credentials through Mr Peter Broughton's Looking Up: A History of the Royal Society of Canada (Toronto and Oxford: Dundurn Press, 1994; now available digitally at https://www.rasc.ca/sites/default/files/LookingUp-300-text.pdf), and in recent months through this same authority's Northern Star (University of Toronto Press, 2018; this new book is a biography of Canadian astrophysicist John Stanley Plakett (1865-1941)). I would be happy to write on the post-2007 conservation effort, drawing on my archive, and could also offer some modest degree of supporting insight for the writer or writers tackling two more remote key periods - on the one hand the years immediately preceding the formal DDO opening of 1935-05-31, and on the other hand the 1960s-1970s upswing in DDO research, led by a bevy of then-young workers, including my own cherished mentor, the late Prof. Robert F. Garrison (1936-2017). 
  • Should efforts not now be made, in proper concert with the Town, to establish a formal Mondays-through-Fridays daytime office-and-library presence, by the RASC national administration, at DDO? If such a move from the present RASC headquarters were to be carried out with boldness and vision (I write here as an outsider, unbriefed on the logistics), then the national profile of RASC would be enhanced, and the Town itself would be making a contribution to the cultural life of the nation.
I might add in an informal way that any visitors from RASC would be welcome to stay a few nights in my upcoming new accommodations at dark-sky Tõravere - provided, that is, they do not mind being a full 20 minutes away from Tartu by rail (and from the railway platform to the Tõravere national-observatory hamlet is an additional, pleasant, rural walk of 2 kilometres), and provided they do not mind sleeping on such things as memory-foam slabs, either in my austere private sleeping cell or in my equally austere private workroom. (In either case, these rather formidable accommodations would be on the ground floor of the Brezhnev-era horror which is Tõravere's "Observatooriumi  tänav 5/ Number 5 Observatooriumi Street". An advantage of living in your hamlet's sole "Brezhnevka" is that as you look out the windows, you do not see any Brezhnevkas.)


(D) I likewise engaged in fully happy diplomacy with DDOD on 2018-06-09, with a correctly friendly level of understanding achieved, or more accurately reiterated. I think it is fair to say that DDOD and I agree on the need to keep in view some possible DDO-Tõravere collaboration, in some such field as Johnson-Cousins UBV stellar photometry. I would privately hope either (a) for the DDOD's Dr Ian Shelton coming on board as the Principal Investigator in some joint observational project or (b) for some Tõravere scientist to become Principal Investigator, taking Dr Shelton as second-in-command. In either of these two scenarios, I would envisage myself coming up the gangplank in a rather junior Tõravere capacity, with lots of night work - in naval terms, becoming one of those reticent chappie-wappies who get to wear just a single gold band on the jacket sleeve.


In view of the favourable diplomacy, it is appropriate to take 2018-06-09 as the formal end of the "DDO&P Conflict" which formally began on 2007-09-10, with the University of Toronto announcing its unwise decision to sell.

It would be easy, in this time of peace, reconciliation, and reconstruction, to offer some of the strong music of Estonia. But I did enough along those particular musical lines in my blogspot posting of 2018-05-22, headed "Operatsiooni 'Kodune Koli' Manööver 'Luureretk' Edukas/ Success in Operation 'Domestic Clobber', 'Preliminary Recce Manoeuvre'", by mentioning YouTube user AndrusEST's 2009-08-01 upload of "Eesti Lipp". I prefer now to turn instead to our northern brothers-in-arms.

I suppose one would profitably consider that salute to the Winter War veterans which has the YouTube heading "Veteraanin Iltahuuto" (upload of YouTube user Mika Tanninen, to a duration of 0:04:27; in my present particular corner of the Internet, in Canada, the material is available at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=arKxCiTZoyQ).

However, I instead choose to put the focus onto a very familiar thing indeed, the usual bit of Sibelius. For this I would specifically recommend the YouTube upload headed "Jean Sibelius - Finlandia" (with a viewcount, as at UTC=20180611T1607Z, of 5,337,303, from YouTube user Tarja M, to a duration of 0:09:36). In my present particular corner of the Internet, that musical material is available at https://www.youtube.c5,337,303 om/watch?v=F5zg_af9b8c.

The woodland depicted in my chosen "Finlandia" vid resonates, I admit, with three or four orders of magnitude more spiritual power than anything we are used to in the modest (and beleaguered) woods surrounding DDO. Conceding the spiritual mismatch, I ask my readers to think less of the modest physical realities of DDO&P than of national cultural and environmental heritage in general, and of the need to defend such heritage with the valour of those Winter War Finns.

[This is the end of the current blog posting.]

Tuesday, 5 June 2018

PUBLIC-SERVICE POSTING: Facebook operations of Town Councillor Karen Cilevitz

Revision history:

  • 20180610T1428Z/version 1.1.0: Kmo added better particulars on YouTube coverage of the Karen Cilevitz case.
  • 20180605Z/version 1.0.0: Kmo uploaded base version. 

The purpose of this posting is to document Town of Richmond Hill Ward Five Councillor Karen Cilevitz's suppression of free public debate on her Facebook page https://www.facebook.com/karencilevitz/, in the wake of the controversy surrounding her legal attack on a civilian (as documented by the CBC in English at http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/councillor-ward-five-1.4685963 under the headline "Richmond Hill councillor leaves threatening voicemail over name of open mic night" and in French at http://www.sympatico.ca/actualites/nouvelles/politique/des-residents-se-sentent-harceles-par-leur-conseillere-municipale-1.3856746 under the headline "Des résidents se sentent harcelés par leur conseillère municipale", and by the local broadcaster "640am", and by "Rebel Media".

The "640am" material was uploaded 2018-05-31 to YouTube by YouTube user Matt Groopie under the heading "Richmond Hill Ward 5 Councillor Karen Cilevitz threatens and berates stage 4 Cancer Patient", to a length of 0:04:44, with subsequent (surely uncensored?) commentary from various people (including me). In my present corner of the Internet, in Canada, the YouTube upload, including comments, may be viewed at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EMK7xMv4OIU). As at UTC=20180610T1426, this upload had a viewcount ot 1,207.

The "Rebel Media" material was uploaded 2018-06-xx to YouTube by YouTube user Rebel Media under the heading "Ward 5 Councillor’s 'threats' to shut down musical acts baffles residents", to a length of 0:11:08, with subsequent (surely uncensored?) commentary from various people, including me. In my present corner of the Internet, in Canada, the YouTube upload, including comments, may be viewed at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YBzt5jfE3zY. As at UTC=20180610T1424Z, this upload had a viewcount of 9,177.

I provide this documentation on the one hand to facilitate public debate, and on the other hand to support the Town of Richmond Hill Integrity Commissioner in any conceivable ongoing Commissioner investigation. 

The documentation forms part of my ongoing effort to illuminate the municipal, provincial, and federal Canadian heritage-conservation failure surrounding Richmond Hill's David Dunlap Observatory and Park (DDO&P). The legacy DDO&P, as created in 1935 and enlarged in the 1950s, comprised 77 hectares. A partial failure in conservation has led to the conversion of a 45-hectare DDO&P rump into a new municipal park, styled the "David Dunlap Observatory Park", with the research-and-public-outreach astrophysical role of DDO presently reduced to a mere public-outreach role. The remaining 32 hectares has become a housing development, promoted at   http://myobservatoryhill.ca/. Councillor Cilevitz has been a proponent of this unsatisfactory outcome. 

My previous involvements with Councillor Cilevitz are documented in this present blog (it is helpful to Google under such strings as Karmo blogspot DDO), and also in my two Web sites http://www.karen-vs-toomas-blog.ca/ and http://www.karen-vs-toomas-legaldocs.ca/


The controversy documented in the above-cited CBC and "640am" broadcast materials started around 2018-05-30 or 2018-05-31. On monitoring https://www.facebook.com/karencilevitz/ rather unsystematically from 2018-05-31 or so onward, I noticed a thing I have also noticed one, two, or three or so times in the past three or four years - namely, the disappearance from https://www.facebook.com/karencilevitz/ of reader comment criticizing Councillor Cilevitz, shortly after her critic does an upload. I was a little slow in documenting what I was noticing. By 2016-06-01, however, I had  embarked on a systematic process of monitoring, through the taking of screenshots on my Debian GNU/Linux workstation. I display the most pertinent of my various screenshots here.

In all cases the screenshot filename incorporates date and local civil time, in the style "YYYY-MM-DD" and "hh-mm-ss". The screenshots show not only my browser (Firefox), but additionally a clock, displaying local civil time to a precision of better than plus-minus 50 milliseconds. As is usual in blogspot publishing, each browser-view screenshot image can, if desired, be enlarged with a left mouse-click.

(A) When I began my formal monitoring, with a screenshot whose filename incorporated the chronological reference 2018-06-01 12-36-17, Facebook user Ray Litvak had uploaded a sleepyhead image, and Facebook user Donn Dixon had uploaded the communication I honestly can't believe that you are harassing people about a name that you do not own....disgusting !!!.


A screenshot whose filename incorporates the chronological reference 2018-06-01 13-48-54 shows the Facebook user Ray Litvak image retained, but the Facebook user  Donn Dixon communication deleted:

(B) On my next day of monitoring, 2018-06-02, I found the Facebook user Ray Litvak image retained, and from Facebook user Dave Clews the communication Sorry, but what a ridiculous waste of time. Hopefully no taxpayer funds were wasted on this., and from Facebook user Ray Litvak the communication Shame, and from Facebook user Dan Page the communication That was a lot of wind expelled in one sitting., and from Facebook user Gerry Hall the communication What you're not admitting is that as a city councillor, you either had no idea how the law works, or you made a threat to take legal action you knew couldn't happen. So what is it - did you REALLY think that legally only city councillors could use the term ward'? Or did you know that was crap, but were hoping they'd give in because you threatened legal action? Either way, you look incredibly petty in this matter.  You were obsessed with stopping someone calling an event the Ward 5 Jam'?! - I can't believe you didn't have better ways to spend your time.:

Later that same day, I found the Facebook user Ray Litvak image deleted, and the Facebook user Dave Clews communication retained, and the Facebook user Ray Litvak communication deleted, and from Facebook user Lori Lewis the communication No situation could ever justify the kind of message that was left. It is shameful:

Still later that same day, I found that all material critical of Councillor Cilevitz within this Facebook discussion thread had been deleted:

(C) On my next fruitful day of monitoring (the last day documented here at blogspot), 2018-06-04, at 09:07 local time, I found from Facebook user Jon Brooks the communication Whatever get over it and let people use words as they wish., and from Facebook user Buck Dallas the communication I also want to start a Ward 5 jam, who is the  contact in the original Ward 5 Jam so that I may ask permission? Please leave a message for me if you have any concerns., and from Facebook user Ryan McGarry-McNab the communication The easiest thing for people to do is to listen to the voicemail left by  the councillor and decide for themselves: http://ajournalofmusicalthings.com/a-city-councillor-is-pissed-over-an-open-mic-night-for-a-very-silly-reason/, and from Facebook user Howard Bayne the communication This is a very well-worded statement. To learn more about her TRUE character listen to the voicemail and hear for yourself.:

Later that same day, I found that within this Facebook discussion thread, all material critical of Councillor Cilevitz had been deleted. Since the deletion was performed on a business day (a Monday) at some time between 09:07 and 09:58 (in other words, in business hours), there is some (less-than-conclusive) presumption that if the deletion was indeed performed by Councillor Cilevitz, then it was performed in her office, during her office hours, with a Town computer rather than with her own personal home computer:  

[This is the end of the current blog posting.]

Tuesday, 22 May 2018

Toomas Karmo: Operatsiooni "Kodune Koli" Manööver "Luureretk" Edukas/ Success in Operation "Domestic Clobber", "Preliminary Recce Manoeuvre"

Päripäeva, alates parema serva alumisest nurgast: (1) Nagu on traditsiooniks kujunenud Tallinna Tehnika Ülikooli külastajatele, surun ka mina igavese tudengi Julius Tipikase kätt. Julius olevat oma pika elu jooksul teeninud hulgaliselt nii magistri- kui ka doktorikraade, mitmes eriaines. Perekonnafoto, tehtud 2018-05-15. (2) Eesti kurvem külg (a): mahajäänud tsaariaegseid laevatase tööliselamuid Kopli ranna juures, Tallinnas. Mulle on seletatud, et raekoda on püüdnud neile peremeest leida, kes suudaks nad konverteerida luksuskorteriteks, kuid et ettenähtud projekt on osutunud tehnilisil põhjusil ebareaalseks. Seejärel lammutamisele mõistetud elamud moodustavad omaette kvartali (mis siin vaid osaliselt pildistatud), rohkete munakivisillutistega. Ajalooise kvartali asemele tulevad tuliuued korterid, kusjuures (nagu mulle seda seletati) püütakse arhitektuuriliselt meenutada kadunud tsaariaegsete korpuste profiile. Perekonnafoto, tehtud 2018-05-15. (3) Eesti kurvem külg (b): praegu veel hoolsa peremeheta Eesti Teaduste Akadeemia 1938-1940 ruumid Laial tänaval Tartus. Tartu Ülikooli püüdlused leida sobivat ostjat ei ole seni vilja kandnud. Foto allikaks on ajalehe Postimees veeb. (4) Kontradmiral Johan Pitka (1872-1944), nagu teda maalis umbes 2005.a. Välis-Eesti kunstnik Erik Schmidt (kelle onuks oli Naissaarelt pärit optikainsener Bernhard Schmidt (1879-1935;  laiaväljalise astronoomilise "Schmidti kaamera" leiutaja)). Maali kõrval seisab kingituse üleandmise ajal olnujd kaitsevägede juhataja (viitseadmiral) Tarmo Kõuts (1953-). Foto allikaks on http://www.mil.ee/et/arhiiv/5153/v%C3%A4liseestlasest-kunstnik-maalis-kaitsev%C3%A4ele-admiral-johan-pitka-portree. Ma olen sellest  www.mil.ee fotomaterjalist osa maha lõiganud, kompaktsuse ja elavuse huvides. (5) Guugeldamisega leitud Tallinna profiil (allikas kahjuks minu märkmetes jäädvustamata). (6) Tartu Toomkiriku varemed, mille ühes osas asus rektor Georg Friedrich Parroti ajast (1802.a.?) kuni 1982.a. Tartu Ülikooli pearaamatukogu. Praegu, kus pearamatukogu on viidud Toomemäelt pisut allapoole, asub tema endistes Toomkiriku ruumides ülikooli muuseum. Toomikiriku kõrval on mälestatud luuletaja Kristian Jaak Peterson (1801-1822), ilmselt oma jalamatkal Tartust (kus ta oli tudeng) Riiga (kus elasid tema vanemad). Jalgade juures seisavad tema järgmised read: "Kas siis selle maa keel/ laulu tuules ei või/ taevani tõustes üles/ igavikku omale otsida?" Foto allikaks on http://kerstilinask.swiftfish.org/about-tartu-university/. Nagu ikkagi blogspot'is, on pakutud pilt hiireklõpsuga suurendatav. - Clockwise, starting from the bottom-right corner: (1) As has become traditional for visitors to the Tallinn University of Technology, so I too shake the hand of the eternal student Julius Tipikas ("A-plus Julius"). Julius is said over his long lifetime to have procured numerous master's and doctorate degrees, covering a wide range of disciplines. Family photo, from 2018-05-15. (2) Estonia's sadder side (a): derelict tsarist workers' accommodations, from the shipyard at the Kopli shore in Tallinn. It has been explained to me that City Hall has tried to find an owner who would be capable of converting these buildings into luxury flats, but that the envisaged project has proved not technically feasible. The buildings, which are now consequently slated for demolition, make up a whole neighbourhood (here seen only in part), with an abundance of cobblestone paving. In place of the heritage neighbourhood will come brand-new flats, whose design (it has been explained to me) will seek to recall the architectural profile of the lost tsarist structures. Family photo, from 2018-05-15. (3) Estonia's sadder side (b): the 1938-1940 offices of the Estonian Academy of Sciences (Academia scientiarvm Estoniae). The efforts by Tartu University to find a suitable purchaser have so far not borne fruit. Photo from the Web site of newspaper Postimees. (4) Rear Admiral Sir Johan Pitka (1872-1944), as depicted around 2005 by Diaspora-Estonia painter Erik Schmidt (who had as an uncle the optical engineer, from Estonia's Naissaar island, Bernhard Schmidt (1879-1935; inventor of the wide-field astronomical "Schmidt Camera")). Beside the painting, at the moment of its handover to the defence forces, stands the then commander-in-chief (Vice-Admiral) Tarmo Kõuts (1953-). The photo is from http://www.mil.ee/et/arhiiv/5153/v%C3%A4liseestlasest-kunstnik-maalis-kaitsev%C3%A4ele-admiral-johan-pitka-portree. I have cropped this www.mil.ee photo material in the interest of compactness and vivacity. (5) A profile of Tallinn found by googling (with source unfortunately not recorded in my notes). (6) The ruins of the Tartu cathedral, in one part of which was located, from the time of rector Georg Friedrich Parrot (1802?) until 1982, the University's main library. Now, with the main library transferred to a site a little below the heights of Toompea, those cathedral rooms instead house the University museum. Beside the cathedral stands a memorial to poet Kristian Jaak Peterson (1801-1822), here evidently depicted on his hike from Tartu (where he was a university student) to Riga (where his parents were living). At his feet are his lines "Kas siis selle maa keel/ laulu tuules ei või/ taevani tõustes üles/ igavikku omale otsida?" ("Cannot then this land's speech,  rising heavenward on the winds of Song, seek eternity for itself?"). The photo source is http://kerstilinask.swiftfish.org/about-tartu-university/. As is normal in blogspot publishing, the image enlarges when mouse-clicked.

Kvaliteedihinnang: - Quality assessment:

Selle viiepallilise skaala kohaselt, mis kehtib praegu Eestis, ja kindlasti ka naaberriikides, ja on tuttav kadunud, mitte tagantjärele leinatud, NSVL-i akadeemilise elu vaatlejatele (siin rakendades neid kergeid, lõtvu, kriteeriume, mida Kmo rakendab oma nõgises fantaseeritud "Aleksandr Stepanovitsh Popovi nimelises sangarliku raadio instituudis" ja oma nõgises fantaseeritud "Nikolai Ivanovitsh Lobatshevki nimelises sotsialistliku matemaatika instituudis" - kus, fantaasias ette kujutatud kaksikinstituutide lõdva ja vähenõudliku hindamisreeglite kohaselt 1/5 on "eepiline läbikukkukmine", 2/5 "läbikukkumine, mis poli nii katastrofaalne, et eepilusust saavutada", 3/5 on "kehvavõitu läbipääsemine", 4/5 on "hea" ja 5/5 on "eeskujulik": 3/5. Põhjendus: Kmo'l oli piisavalt aega seletada vajalikke punkte sobivas pikkuses, kuid materjal oli paratamatult kergekaaluline. -  On the 5-point scale current in Estonia, and surely in nearby nations, and familiar to observers of the academic arrangements of the late, unlamented, Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (applying the easy and lax standards Kmo deploys in his grubby imaginary "Aleksandr Stepanovitsh Popovi nimeline sangarliku raadio instituut" (the "Alexandr Stepanovitch Popov Institute of Heroic Radio") and his  grubby imaginary "Nikolai Ivanovitsh Lobatshevski nimeline sotsalitsliku matemaatika instituut" (the "Nicolai Ivanovich Lobachevsky Institute of Socialist Mathematics") - where, on the lax and easy grading philosophy of the twin Institutes, 1/5 is "epic fail", 2/5 is "failure not so disastrous as to be epic", 3/5 is "mediocre pass", 4/5 is "good", and 5/5 is "excellent"): 3/5. Justification: although Kmo had time to develop the necessary points to reasonable length, the points themselves were of necessity rather lightweight.

Variandikroonika: - Revision history:

Kõik kalendrip
äevad-kellaajad variandikroonikas on ära toodud UTC-s. UTC, ehk "Maailmakell", on vana GMT-i, ehk "Greenwich Mean Time"-i, täpsustus. Tarvitusel on ISO ettekirjutatud YYYYMMDDThhmmZ ajastembi formaat (kusjuures YYYY on UTC aasta, MM UTC kuu, DD UTC kuupäev, hh UTC tunniarv, mm UTC minutiarv). UTC praegu jookseb Toronto tsiviilkellast (suvekellast) 4 tundi ette, Tallinna-Tartu tsiviilkellast (suvekellast) 3 tundi taga. - All times in these blog "revision histories" are stated in UTC (Universal Coordinated Time/ Temps Universel Coordoné,  a precisification of the old GMT, or "Greenwich Mean Time"), in the ISO-prescribed YYYYMMDDThhmmZ timestamping format. UTC currently leads Toronto civil time (summer time) by 4 hours and currently lags Tallinn-Tartu civil time (summer time) by 3 hours.
  • 20180530T0201Z/variant 3.2.0: Kmo parandas vihjed Tõravere spetsidele, olles uurinud nende ametikoha nimetusi ja teaduslikke kraade lehelt https://www.to.ee/est/meist/koosseis. Ta ka lisas vihjet uudisterartiklile https://www.to.ee/est/uudised/eFJlMzEwMjZz/atraktsioonide_park_avati_p_auml_ikselise_perep_auml_evaga. Ta jättis enda kätte õiguse teha veel pisikesi, sisusliselt tähtsusetuid, puhtkosmeetilisi õiendusi, järgmise 48 tunni jooksul, kui siin protkollimata variandid 3.2.1, 3.2.2, 3.2.3, ... . - Kmo improved his references to some Tõravere specialists, having now checked their qaualifications and formal staff designations from https://www.to.ee/eng/about_us/staff.  He also added a reference to the news report at https://www.to.ee/eng/news/eFJlMzEwMjZz/observatory_rsquo_s_theme_park_was_opened_with_a_sunny_family_dayHe reserved the right to make tiny, nonsubstantive, purely cosmetic, tweaks over the coming 48 hours, as here-undocumented version 3.2.1, 3.2.2, 3.2.3, ... .
  • 20180524T2328Z/variant 3.1.0: Kmo tegi pisimuudadusi eestikeeles osas ja lihvis ingliskeelset osa, ja veel lisas fotomaterjali. Ta jättis enda kätte õiguse teha veel pisikesi, sisusliselt tähtsusetuid, puhtkosmeetilisi õiendusi, järgmise 48 tunni jooksul, kui siin protkollimata variandid 3.1.1, 3.1.2, 3.1.3, ... .  - Kmo made some small changes in the Estonian, polished the English portion,  and added photo material. He reserved the right to make tiny, nonsubstantive, purely cosmetic, tweaks over the coming 48 hours, as here-undocumented version 3.1.1, 3.1.2, 3.1.3, ... .
  • 20180523T1955Z/variant 3.0.0: Kmo lihvis eestiskeelset proosat ja lisas (veel lihvimata) ingliskeese tõlke. Ta lootis mõlemat keelt veel lihvida, ja ka lisada natuke fotomaterjali, järgmise 24. tunni jooksul. - Kmo polished his Estonian prose and added (as yet unpolished) English translations. He hoped to polish his work in both languages, and also to add a little bit of photo material, over the coming 24 hours.
  • 20180523T0330Z/variant 2.0.0: Kmo suutis konverteerida kondikava korralikku proosasse, ehk täislausetesse, kuid ei leidnud veel aega lihvimiseks-kontrollimiseks ega tõlkimiseks inglise keelde. Ta lootis kõik lõpetada enne UTC=20180523T2000Z. - Kmo managed to convert his outline into correct full-sentences prose, but lacked the time for checking and polishing, and for writing out the requisite English translations. He hoped to finish everything by UTC=20180523T2000Z.
  • 20180523T0113Z/variant 1.0.0: Kmo laadis serverile lihvitud kondikava, peamiselt eesti keeles. Ees ootasid (a) kondikava konverteerimine korralikku proosasse (täislausetes), ning (b) korraliku proosa eestikeelse osa tõlkimine inglise keelde. Ta lootis neid töid läbi viia enne UTC=20180523T0330Z. - Kmo uploaded a polished outline, for the most part in Estonian. He now had (a) to convert the outline into correct full-sentences prose and (b) to translate the Estonian portion of his prose into English. He hoped to complete these tasks before UTC=20180523T0330Z.

[HOIATAV TEAVE: Tunduvalt vigane bloggeri-nimeline serveri tarkvara on viimaste kuude jooksul näidanud kalduvusi paigutada soovimatut valgevahet niimõnesse siia laaditud esseesse. Kui tundub, et ekraan lõpeb tühja ruumiga, tuleb veel allapoole liikuda, hiire abil. Essee lõpp ei ole käes enne, kui esineb tavaline bloggeri sõnum "Posted by Toomas (Tom) Karmo at". - Bloggeri tarkvara on ka näidanud kalduvusi, vähemalt kui rakendatud minu varema, aegunud, veebi esseedekirjutamise brauseri kaudu, toota HTML-i, mida eri allalaadivad brauserid formaadivad erinevatel viisidel. Mõned allalaadivad brauserid on võimalikult vahest mitte korralikult sisse lugenud kõik need "Cascading Style Sheets'e" (CSS-e), mis igas tavalises veebibrausers juhivad lehekülje servade, kõrvalparagrahvide jms. paigutamist. Kui Te oletate, et Teie kasutuselevõetud brauseris esineb CSS-e probleeme, olge kannatlikud: tõenäone on, et ehkki osa sisust on paigutatud mõnda veidrasse kohta (näiteks, brauseri alumise serva vastu, kui ta pidanuks minema parema serva vastu), siiski kõik serveri sisu on lükatud Teie brauserisse ühte või teisse kätteleitavasse paika. - Viimaseks, on võimalik et on bloggeri iseärasusi-eksitusi, väljaspool minu kontrolli, tähtede suuruse määramises, ridade vahemaa määramises või trükiploki parema serva õgvendamisstiili määramises. - Kes soovib aidata sääraste veebivigade parandamisega, või kes soovib ka teisigi tehnilisi nõuandeid pakkuda, võiks julgesti mulle kirjutada aadressil Toomas.Karmo@gmail.com. - CAUTION: A bug in the blogger server-side software has in some past months shown a propensity to insert inappropriate whitespace at some points in some of my posted essays. If a screen seems to end in empty space, keep scrolling down. The end of the posting is not reached until the usual blogger "Posted by Toomas (Tom) Karmo at" appears. - The blogger software has also shown a propensity, at any rate when coupled with my erstwhile, out-of-date, Web-authoring uploading browser, to generate HTML that gets formatted in different ways on different downloading browsers. Some downloading browsers have sometimes perhaps not correctly read in the entirety of the "Cascading Style Sheets" (CSS) which on all ordinary Web servers control the browser placement of margins, sidebars, and the like. If you suspect CSS problems in your particular browser, be patient: it is probable that while some content has been shoved into some odd place (for instance, down to the bottom of your browser, where it ought to appear in the right-hand margin), all the server content has been pushed down into your browser in some place or other. - Finally, there may be blogger vagaries, outside my control, in font sizing or interlinear spacing or right-margin justification. - Anyone inclined to help with trouble-shooting, or to offer other kinds of technical advice, is welcome to write me via Toomas.Karmo@gmail.com.]

0. Sissejuhatus/ Introduction

Minu maikuiseks bloggimiseks paneksin kirja oma praeguse suure uudise, nimelt, et Operatsiooni "Kodune Koli" manööver "Luureretk" on edukalt läbi viidud. Lahkumine Kanadast odava lendudekombinatsiooniga oli 2018-04-23, saabumine Kanadasse odava lendudekombinatsiooniga New Yorgi üleöise vahepeatusega (tukkumisega LaGuardia lennujaama ooteruumis) 2018-05-17. Enne lõplikku emigreerumist Kanadast seisavad veel ees (nagu siin blogspot-is 2018-04-02 ka kirejeldatud) (a) osa manöövrist "Mõnus Maandumine", ja veel (b) "Merelesaatmise Suurmanööver" ning (c) "Pearsoni Lõppmanööver". - As my blog offering for the month of May, I should like to write out my current piece of big news, namely, the successful completion, within "Operation Eastward Ho", of the "Preliminary Recce Manoeuvre". Departure from Canada, with a cheap combination of flights, was on 2018-04-23. The return, via a cheap combination of flights, and with a New York stopover (and with overnight napping in a LaGuardia concourse) was on 2018-05-17. Before my final emigration from Canada there await (as indeed described here on blogspot, on 2018-04-02) (a) part of the "Happy Landing Manoeuvre", and (b) the "Big Maritime Shipment Manoeuvre", with (c) the "Pearson Airport Endmanoeuvre".

Loodan, et saan kõik lõpuni viia, seega asudes alaliselt ümber Tõravere astroomia-alevikku Tartumaal, kunagi 2018.a. sügisel. - I hope that I can complete everything, settling permanently into the Tõravere observatory hamlet in Estonia's Tartu County, in the autumn of 2018.

1. Üldisi Muljeid Kodu-Eestist/ Some General Impressions of Home- (as Opposed to Diaspora-) Estonia

Tunnen vähem sisemist pinget Kodu-Eestis kui Välis-Eestis, kuna Kodu-Eestis saab emakeelt julgesti rääkida. Emakeele kasutamine muutub Välis-Eestis aastast aastasse raskemaks. Ennesõjaaegne põlv on manalasse varisemas, ja kolm nooremad põlved on üldreeglina - leidub ka rõõmutoovaid erandeid - kõikuva keeleoskusega. - I experience less inner stress in Home-Estonia than in Diaspora-Estonia, since it is in Home-Estonia that using the mother tongue becomes fully feasible. Within the diaspora, the use of Estonian is becoming from year to year less feasible. The prewar diaspora generation is dying away, and the three younger diaspora generations as a general rule labour - with, to be sure, happy exceptions - under various linguistic challenges.


Hingelisi pingeid Eestis leevendab veel looduse erakorraline lähesus. Looduse kättesaadavuse osas sarnaneb Eesti pigem Kanada Nova Scotia kui Kanada Ontario provintsiga. - Inner stresses in Estonia are also relieved by the exceptional nearness of nature. In its proximity to the natural world, Estonia is more similar to Canada's province of Nova Scotia than to Ontario.

Sõites bussiga Tallinna Ülemiste lennujaamast Tartu kesklinnani on siiski üllatuseks, kuivõrd sarnaneb Kodu-Eesti maastikupilt lõuna-Ontario vähemasusustatud osadega. Kodu-Eesti kasemetsad tunduvad mulle küll Ontario omadest tihedamad ja arvukamad, kusjuures tüved on ka vist sirgemad. Ma ei tea veel, kas tegemist on siin liikide erinevusega. Kui mitte kasemetsadele vaadata, siis puhta looduse pildi järgi ei saaks aru, läbi mille riigi buss sõidab. - Upon travelling by bus from the Tallinn-Ülemiste airport to the Tartu town centre, it is nevertheless surprising how closely the Home-Estonia landscape resembles those parts of southern Ontario which are sparsely settled. The birch forests of Home-Estonia do, on the other hand, seem to me thicker and more numerous than those of Ontario, with the birch trunks being perhaps also straighter. I do not yet know whether this is due to a difference in botanical species. The birches aside, one cannot tell from the natural landscape through which of the two countries one's bus happens to be travelling.

Eesti on Kanadast natuke moodsam, aga samas Kanadast tunduvalt vaesem. Kurvalt torkavad silma hooned, kas NSVL-i okupatsiioniajast või enne maailmasõda (tihti koguni tsaaride ajast), kellel veel, juba veerand sajandit pärast okupatsioonivägede lahkumist, puudub korralik peremees. See Kanada vaatepilti häiriv asi, mis on globaalse hullmajanduse Walmartide-Macdonaldsite rohkus, torkab kohati ka Eestis silma, eriti magisraalteede juures linnades. - Estonia is a little more modern than, and yet at the same time noticeably poorer than, Canada. A sad sight is presented by buildings, whether from the time of the Soviet occupation or from before the war (and in many case from tsarist times) which still, a quarter of a century after the departure of occupation forces, lack duly diligent owners. That distressing Canadian sight which is the proliferation of globalizing commercial stupidity, through such things as Walmart and MacDonalds, likewise crops up in Estonia, particularly beside the major traffic arteries in towns. 


Võõra kaasmaalase viisakus on tähelepanuväärne Kodu-Eesis nagu nendes Välis-Eesti lõikudes, mida ma hästi tunnen, nimelt Austraalias-Kanadas-USAs-Suurbritannias. - The courtesy of compatriots who happen to be strangers is notable in Home-Estonia, as it is in those segments of Diaspora-Estonia that I know well (namely, in the Australian, Canadian, USA, and British diaspora communities).                


Nagu mulle tuntud Välis-Eesti lõikudes, näib, et  ka Kodu-Eestis pannakse tunduvat rõhku toitude kvaliteedile. Kui Välis-Eestis minu Nova Scotia lapsepõlves oli näiteks perenaise auks ja uhkuseks heade sültide-skumbriate-pashade-kringlite valmistamine pidude ajaks, analoogselt leian ma praegu Kodu-Eestis märgatavalt kõrget taset muuseas leibade, juustude, kohukeste ja mõru šokolaadi osas. - As in those parts of Diaspora-Estonia which I know, so too in Home-Estonia much attention is given to the quality of food. As in the Diaspora-Estonia of my Nova Scotia childhood the housewife took pride in the preparation of her head-cheeses, her chilled fish salad, her sweet egg-and-dairy pasha, and her saffron coffeecake, analogously I find now in Home-Estonia a notably high standard in (among other things) breads, cheeses, dairy confectionery-batons, and bitter chocolate. 


Kanada ja Kodu-Eesti asustatud paikade üldpildid erinevad kultuurselt. Kanadas on vaid hõre ajalookiht, kui mitte arvesse võtta Québec'i provintsi prantsusmaalikku omapära. Lõuna-Ontarios see kiht ulatub vaid Napoleoni sõdade ajasse, kohati vaid kuninganna Victoria lõppaastateni. Pärismaalased, ehkki umbes niisama iidsed Ontarios kui seda on eestlased Eestis, ei ole jätnud Ontario talude, külade ega linnade pilti silmatorkavat omapära. Eestis on seevastu sama tihe ja raskekaaluline ajalookiht nagu seda leidub Inglismaal või (nagu ma piltidelt ja inimeste juttudest oletaksin) Venemaal. - The general cutural aspects of the settled regions in Canada and in Home-Estonia differ. Canada has only a thin historical overlay, once one disregards the specially Gallic heritage of Québec. In southern Ontario, that overlay extends only into the time of the Napoleonic wars, and in places only into the later years of Queen Victoria. The aboriginals, although about as ancient in Ontario as the Estonians are in Estonia, have not left a visually prominent mark on Ontario's agricultural, village, or urban scenes. In Estonia, by contrast, the historical overlay is as thick and massive as it is in England or (as I would imagine it, on the strength of pictures and of what people tell me) Russia.

Eesti keskaegki on ettekujutav, osaliselt tänu säilinud kitsastele tänavatele ja madalatele majaprofiilidele. Eesti hiline tsaariaeg (nagu Eesti hilisemadki ajad) vaatab igal pool vastu, kas mornilt või rõõmsalt. Tooksin sellest vaid üht näidet kümnetest võimalikkudest: Tartu Vallikraavi-Lossi tänava kandis kõndides märkasin pretensioonideta tõllakuuri, mis muinsuskaitse plakati järgi pärines umbes aastast 1875. Kerge oli seal vaimusilmaga näha, kuidas madala kuuri laiadest ustest väljub hobune ja vanker, hobuste ohjad mõne eestlasest kutsari peos, kutsar kodokootud joppes - ja kuidas vankrit ja kutsarit maja juures ootab mõni paremini riietatud saksasoost või kadakasklasest "Tante" oma "Herraga".- Even the Middle Ages in Estonia can be pictured readily, in part thanks to the surviving narrow streets and the low skylines of homes. Estonia's later tsarist period (as also for Estonia's more recent historical periods) confronts one everywhere, whether in sorrow or in good humour. I would give just one example here, out of dozens of possible examples: walking in the Tartu Vallikraavi ("Moat Street" and Lossi tänav ("Castle Street") district, I came across an unpretentious coach house, which according to its heritage-conservation plaque dated from around 1875. It was easy to see in the mind's eye how from those wide coach-house doors there emerge a horse and cart, with the reins in the hands of some Estonian coachman in his homespun jacket - and how by the house there stand, awaiting the cart and its attendant, some better-dressed German or Juniper-German "Tante" with her "Herra". [NOTE ADDED: The "Juniper Germans" were 19th-century and early 20th-century Estonians who affected German manners, for example by speaking some German in the dining room, or by leaving some German newspapers in view in the parlour, or by cultivating social ties with some local German Lady-of-Fine-Family. Old Estonia was always more a German colony than a Russian one. The German conquest started in 1208, whereas Russian rule was significantly imposed only in the period from Peter the Great up to the 1918-1920 War of Independence. Even during the tsarist period, much legal and university business was transacted in German. I think many or most local people resented the whole protracted soap opera, from one weary century to the next - with, in particular, those 19th-century locals who did affect some German manners drawing upon their heads a certain nuanced ridicule from the more patriotically upright. Our short 16th-century Polish occupation, in southern-central Estonia, is now largely forgotten. I personally consider this lack of interest in Polish administration a pity. - The one thing everyone does remember cheerfully from pre-modern Estonia is the 17th-century "vana hea Rootsi aeg", or "Good Old Swedish Time".] 

Tartus kõndides tundub, et sammun esimest korda elus õigetel tänavatel (vähemalt siis, kui olen magistraalidest eemal, ajaloo keskel, näiteks Vallikraavil). - Walking in Tartu one feels that one is for the first time in one's life walking along the right streets (at any rate when one is away from the big urban arteries, and is consequently surrounded by history - as for instance on Vallikraav). 


2. Momente "Luureretke" Teaduslikust Osast/ Scientific Aspects of the "Preliminary Recce Manoeuvre"

Tõraverega tutvust luues olin õnnelik, et sain ühel avalikul üritusel (vt https://www.to.ee/est/uudised/eFJlMzEwMjZz/atraktsioonide_park_avati_p_auml_ikselise_perep_auml_evaga) esimest korda elus näha Päikese protruberantse. Seda pakuti kõrgetasemelise amatööri refraktori läbi (suurendusega võimalikult nii 40x-50x), mille objektiivi juures oli vesinik-alfa filter. - On getting to know Tõravere, I was fortunate in being able at a public event (cf https://www.to.ee/eng/news/eFJlMzEwMjZz/observatory_rsquo_s_theme_park_was_opened_with_a_sunny_family_day) to see solar prominences, for the first time in my life. This sight was offered through a high-grade amateur refractor (under a magnification of around 40x or 50x), its objective  equipped with a hydrogen-alpha filter.

Samuti olin õnnelik, et sain samal üritusel esimest korda elus näha Veenust päeva ajal, läbi Tõravere suure (1.5-metrise) reflektori kahe refraktorist abiteleskoopi (esiteks läbi sihtija, siis kõrge suurendusega läbi giideri). - I was also fortunate in being able for the first time in my life, at this same public event, to see Venus in the daytime, through two of the big (1.5-metre) Tõravere reflector's auxiliary refractors (first through the finder, and then, under high magnification, through the guider).

Oma enda pisikesi amatöörtõid tehes amatööridele pühendatud Tõravere platsilt märkasin, et Elva linna kardetud kuma ei olnud (mulle) kätteleitav. Taevas oli pealegi sedavõrd pime (terve "Luureretke" juures puudus oluline Kuu), et Linnutee oli selgelt nähtav juba öö algtundidel, kui ta hõljus vaid 30 kraadi, ehk kolm rusikat, üle idahorisondi. - On carrying out my own tiny amateur-astronomy tasks from Tõravere's amateur-astronomy plaza, I found that the feared urban glow from Elva was not (at any rate to me) discerible. The sky was so dark (there was no significant Moon at any point in the Preliminary Recce Manoeuvre) that the Milky Way proved clearly visible already at the start of the night, when it hovered just 30 degrees, or three fists, above the eastern horizon.

Minu lõuna-Kanadas harjunud silmale oli ebamugav, et taeva ekvaator asus nii ligidal lõunahorisondile. Siiski tõdesin, et tänu metsapuude kaugusele Tõravere amatöörideplatsi lõunaservalt, vaade lõunahorisondi poole oli sisuliselt takistusteta. Leidsin oma reisibinokliga kätte mitte ainult alfa Sco-d, vaid koguni lõunataeva tau Sco-d, oma kulminatsioonist vist mitte kaugel. Viimane oli küll vaevalt 1-2 kraadi horisondilt kõrgem. Tema 2018.5 epohhi kääne on -28 kraadi 15 minutit, kusjuures Tõravere enda laius on +58 kraadi 48 minutit. Epohhil 2018.5 oleks seega tau Sco kulminatsiioni nurk vaakumi tingimustes lõunahorisondi vastu vaid (90 kraadi miinus (58 kraadi 48 minutit + 28 kraadi 15 minutit)) = (90 kraadi miinus 87 kraadi 03 minutit) = 2 kraadi 57 minutit; kirjutades siin vaakumi tingimustest, ma toonitan, et valguskiire paindumine horisondiatmosfääri paksus kihis tõstaks näilise tähe küll kõrgemale. - It was uncomfortable to my eye, accustomed as it is to southern Canada, to find the celestial equator running so close to the southern horizon. Nevertheless, I did establish that thanks to the generous distance of trees from the southern edge of the Tõravere amateur-observer plaza, the view to the south is basically unimpeded. With my lightweight travelling binoculars, I found not only alpha Sco, but even the southern-sky tau Sco, I suppose not far away from its culmination. Tau Sco admittedly hovered just one or two degrees above the horizon. Its epoch-2018.5 declination is -28 degrees 15 minutes, with Tõravere's own latitude +58 degrees 48 minutes. Tau Sco's 2018.5 culmination under vacuum would consequently be (90 degrees minus (58 degrees 48 minutes + 28 degrees 15 minutes)) = (90 degrees minus 87 degrees 03 minutes) = 2 degrees 57 minutes; in referring here to vacuum, I am drawing attention to the fact that the refraction of the stellar ray in the thick atmospheric layer at the horizon would raise the apparent star a little higher.

Keerukates reisitingimustes ei olnud võimalik palju matemaatikat õppida. Siiski sain oma armsa sugulase "ABCD" Tartus-asuva laua taga, ja veel Tõravere peahoone kohviku või raamatukogupiirkonna laudade taga, teha mõned tunnid praeguste aktuaalsete probleemide lahendamiseks. Lahke Lugeja saab aimu minu madalast tasemest (oluline magistrikraadki puudub), kui ta lubab mul põgusalt seletada, mis praegu käsil on. Et raadio (Maxwelli) füüsikas edasi jõuda, pean kunagi asetama Maxwelli neli vektoriformalismi võrrandit tensorite-(Eintseini) erirelatiivsuse formalismi. Selleks pean tundma õppima determinanti mitte sedavõrd oma keskkooli-matemaatika ruutmatrikside kontekstis kui väljapaistva tensorite näitena, konkreetsemalt kui paradigmaatiline "alterneeruv tensor". Determinant on defineeritav nii lihtsa Leibnizi kui ka keerukama rekursiivse Laplace'i valemitega. Minu praegune väljakutse on endale tõestada, opereerides Leibnizi valemite permutatsioonideraamistikus, et Laplace'i rekursiivselt definieeritud determinandi mõiste ongi tõepoolest Leibnizi kergemini kirjapandava mõiste ekvivalent. - It was not possible to study much mathematics in the complex circumstances of travel. Nevertheless, I was able behind the table of my dear Tartu relation "ABCD", and again at the Tõravere main-building cafe or library-area tables, to work a few hours toward the solution of my current problems. The Gentle Reader may gain an impression of my low achievement level (even a relevant Master's degree is lacking) by allowing me to explain briefly the work currently in hand. To make progress in the (Maxwell) physics of radio, I must eventually transplant the Maxwell four-vector-equation formalism into the tensor formalism of Einstein's Special Relativity. For this, I must in turn study the determinant, not so much in its high-school operations-with-square-matrices context as in its aspect of a tensor - more concretely, as a specially prominent "alternating tensor". The determinant is definable both with Leibniz's simple expression and with the more complex recursive formulation of Laplace. My current challenge is to prove to myself, working within the permutations framework of Leibniz, that Laplace's recursively defined determinant really is equivalent to Leibniz's more easily expressed quantity. 


Ka sain ma Tõravere kohviku või raamatukogupiirkonna laudade juures teha väikest algust Royal Astronomical Society of Canada (RASC) artikli 2018.a. täiendamises - seega viies edasi algatust, mida RASC-i pere pakub avalikkusele URL-il (autoriteks Karmo-Corbally-Gray) https://www.rasc.ca/supplements, lingi all "This is the extended table mentioned on p. 275 of the 2018 Handbook." - I was also able at the Tõravere cafe or library-area tables to make a small beginning on extending a 2018 Royal Astronomical Society of Canada (RASC) aricle - thereby carring forward an initiative which the RASC family offers to the public at the URL (authors are Karmo-Corbally-Gray) https://www.rasc.ca/supplements, under the hyperlink "This is the extended table mentioned on p. 275 of the 2018 Handbook."

Tõraveres olles sain ma pikemaid arutlusi pidada kolme vanemas seisuses spetsialistiga - vanemteadur dr K. Annuk (keda ma tunnen juba sellest ajast, kui ta tuli Ontario David Dunlapi nimelisse observatooriumi külalisvaatlejana), teadur (nint IT peaspetsialist) hr T. Eenmäe ja vanemteadur dr I. Kolka. Olin veel õnnelik, et sain tutvust luua ühe noorema doktoritöö-valmistajaga, ESTCube-satelliidirühma I. Sünteriga. - While in Tõravere, I was able to have extended conversations with three senior specialists - with Senior Engineer  Dr K. Annuk (whom I know already from the time of his visit to Ontario's David Dunlap Observatory, as a guest observer), with Research Fellow (and IT Senior Specialist) Mr T. Eenmäe, and with Senior Research Fellow Dr I. Kolka. I was addtionally fortunate in being able to form a acquaintance with a younger doctoral student, I. Sünter, from the ESTCube satellite team. 

3. Momente "Luureretke" Administratiivsest Osast/ Administrative Aspects of the "Preliminary Recce Manoeuvre" 

(A) Peamised observatooriumi puudutavad administratiivsed punktid on järgmised: - The following are my principal points regarding observatory administration:

  • On teatud lootusi tulevikus kaasa aidata, vabatahtlikuna, teleskoobivaatleja töös. Teema on teatud määral "Luureretke" jooksul arutatud nii dr Annukiga kui ka dr Eenmäe ja dr Kolkaga. Ma loodaksin (a) rakendada neid oskusi, mida ma omandasin David Dunlapi nimeliseses observatooriumis Ontarios (peamiselt spektroskoopilise ööasistendina ajavahemikul 2006-11/2008-06), ja veel (b) ennast täiendada Johnson-Cousins UBV fotomeetrias. - There is a some prospect of being able to assist in telescope work, as a volunteer. This point got to a certain extent discussed during the "Preliminary Recce Manoeuvre" with Drs. Annuk, Eenmäe, and Kolka. I would hope (a) to use the skills which I acquired at the David Dunlap Observatory in Ontario (mainly as a spectroscopy night assistant in the period 2006-11/2008-06), and (b) to educate myself in Johnson-Cousins UBV photometry.
  • On teadud lootusi tulevikus kaasa aidata, vabatahtlikuna, raamatukogu asjus. Mul oli üsna põhjalik jutuajamine Tõraveres asuva raamatukogu vastava spetsialistiga, pr M. Veldrega. Selle arutelu jooksul mul tekkis paraku mulje, et minu enda keeleoskused ei komplekteeri olulisel määral pr. Veldre omi: minu ladina, muistse-kreeka ja prantsuse oskused ei saa minu meelest olulised olla Tõravere raamatukogunduses, ja minu (küll oluline) olemasolev saksa keel ei lisa midagi olulist sellele oskusele, mis on pr. Veldrel niikuinii olemas. Siiski tundus pr. Veldrele ja mulle, et saaksin vabatahtlikuna kaasa lüüa näiteks andmebaasi täiendamisel, andmete sissekandmisega arvutisse. Ma kasutasin juhust mainida pr. Veldrele, et Tõravere suure teleskoobi tornis on niimõndagi huvitavat, mis tahaks sissekandmist üleriiklikusse ESTER-i raamatukogude üldkatalogi. Seal ma eriti mainisin talle Harvard Annals-e, mis istuvad ühes torniruumis, köidetuna, suures mahus, ja milledes Harvardi Pickering avastas (muuseas?) oma tsaariaegset fotomeetriat. - Veel võiks seda mainida, et pr. Veldre lahkelt julgustas mind istuma nii kohvikulaudade kui ka raamatukogupiirkonna laudade juures oma isikliku (matemaatika-ning-RASC-i) reisikohvris kaasatoodud tööotstega. Ma koguni kasutasin, kellegi unustatud isiku soovitusel, kohviautomaati umbes kolm korda - olles küll iga valmisjoodud kohvi eest nüüd maksma valmis, kui kohviku hooldajad hakaksid minult tagantjärele lõive paluma. Sügisel, kui on mul kavas alaliselt ümber asuda Kanadast Tõraverre, ma loodaksin uuesti arutada Tõravere perega võimaliu töölaua küsimust. Mulle oli praegu, "Luureretke" jooksul, ühelt teadurilt vihjatud võimalusele, et ehk saaksin oma tööotsi tuua mõnda suure teleskoobi kupli all asuvasse ruumi, kus valitseks muuseas Interneti juurdepääs. - There is a certain prospect of assisting as a library volunteer. I had a fairly detailed conversation with the appropriate specialist in the Tõravere astronomical library, Mrs M. Veldre. In the course of our conversation, I unfortunately did get the impression that my present linguistic skills would not complement Mrs Veldre's skills in a useful way: my Latin, classical Greek, and French skills cannot in my view be relevant to Tõravere librarianship, and my (relevant) German does not add anything to Mrs Veldre's existing skillset. Nevertheless, it appeared  to both Mrs Veldre and me that I could usefully assist as a volunteer in database entry at the computer. I used this opportunity to note to Mrs Veldre that the big Tõravere telescope tower has interesting items, which it would now be appropriate to enter into the Republic-wide ESTER all-libraries catalogue. I particularly referred her to the Harvard Annals, which sit in a tower room, duly bound, occupying a generous stretch of shelving, and in which Pickering at Harvard published (among other things?) his tsarist-epoch photometry. - It would be appropriate to add here that Mrs Veldre kindly encouraged me to sit both at the café tables and at the library-area tables with my own (mathematics-and-RASC) work files, as I had brought them in baggage. I indeed went so far as to use the coffee automat three times, at the recommendation of some now-forgotten individual - being, I underscore, now ready to pay for each consumed mug of coffee, should café administrators issue me a retrospective payment request. In the autumn, when I hope to be settling permanently in Tõravere from Canada, I would hope once again to discuss the possible worktable question with the overall Tõravere scientific family. During the current Preliminary Recce Manoeuvre, one of the scientists noted to me the possibility that I might be able in the autumn to take my bits of work into one of the rooms under the big telescope dome, where amenities would include Internet access.
(B) Peamised korterit puudutavad administratiivsed punktid on järgmised: - The following are my principal points regarding administration of living accommodations:

  • Olen loobunud endise observatooriumi kombinaathone "Observatooriumi tn 5" katusekorteri toorpinna ostmise võimalusest, ehkki ma tegin sellest tõsist juttu siinsamas blogspot-is 2018-04-02. Sellest toorpinnast saaks küll kunagi tulevikus huvipakkuv kompaktne korter mõnele hüpoteetilisele isikule, kellel tugevam rahakott ja suurem ehitamislust ku minul endal. - I have relinquished the opportunity of buying raw apartment space in the "5 Observatooriumi Street" penthouse, even though I discussed this opportunity in a serious way (in Estonian) here at blogspot on 2018-04-02. The raw space would in future become an interesting, compact, apartment for some hypothetical individual stronger than me in finances and in enthusiasm for construction.
  • Endises kombinaathoones "Observatooriumi tn 5" on mul üürileping sõlmitud kahe maapealse korruse ühetoase kasuks - tuba "nr. 34" elamiseks (selle pindalaks 18 ruutmeetrit) ning "tuba nr. 38" (kunagine ENSV postkontor) laoks-privaatraamatukoguks-kuivlaboriks (selle pindalaks 38 ruutmeetrit). - In the former observatory multipurpose building "5 Observatooriumi Street", I have entered into a pair of rental agreements in respect of two ground-floor single-room apartments - room "nr. 34" as living space (this has an area of 18 square metres) and room "nr. 38" (formerly a post office of the Estonian Soviet Socialist Republic (ESSR)) as a storeroom, private library, and dry laboratory (this has an area of 38 square metres).
  • Minu lahke insinerist sugulase "BCDE" kaudu sain ma teada, et endise kombinaathoone põrandapaneelid kannavad (juhul, kui nad vastavad selle hoone 1974.a. ehitusajal tavalisele ENSV praksisele) 2.0 kilonjuutonit ruutmeetri peal julgesti, 2.8 kilonjuutonit ruutmeetri peal reservarveldusega. BCDE veel näitas mulle, kuidas aproksimeerida paindmomente ja - mis eriti oluline - põikjõude endise kombinaathoone oludes. Ehkki ma pean asja juures veel mõtisklema, pliiatsite ja ruutpaberiga, oma eelseisvatel Kanada "detailplaneeringu" tundidel, tundub praegu, et saaksin oma privaatraamatukogu ja amatöörraadio katsepinki julgesti paigutada endisesse kombinaathoonesse, ja pealegi, et ei oleks hädavajalik lasta oma detailplaneeringu ohutust kontrollida mõne hüpoteetilise (kalliksmineva?) Tartu arhitekti poolt. - Through my generous and helpful relative "BCDE", I have learned that the former multipurpose-building floor panels support (at any rate, assuming them to correspond to the ESSR building practices current at  the time of construction, back in 1974) 2.0 kilonewtons per square metre as a matter of routine, and 2.8 kilonewtons per square metre upon adding the usual ESSR contingency margin. BCDE additionally showed me how in my scenario to approximate bending moments and - this is particularly important - how in my scenario to approximate shear stresses. Although I still have to ponder this matter, with pencils and squared paper, in my impending hours of Canada-based "detailplaneeering", it does now seem to me that I can boldly enough deposit my private library and my radio-amateur experimenter's bench into the former multipurpose building, and moreover that it will not prove necessary to have this "detailplaneering" checked for safety by some hypothetical (expensive?) Tartu architect.
  • Teatud koolkond minu suguvõsas leiab, et ma hakkan Tõraveres liiga askeetselt elama. Sellele ma aga aupaklikult vastaksin, (a) et laoruum-privaatraamatukogu-kuivlabor "nr. 38-s" võib olla nii askeetlik kui tahes, olgu selle tarbija nii härraslik kui vajalik, ning (b) et elamiseruumi "nr 34-t" saab muuta ilusamaks kardina panemisega (kui peremees selleks loa annab) olemasoleva duššikabiini-köögivalamu kamofleerimiseks. - "(b)" osas ma veel toonitaksin, et sellele koolkonna osaliselt õigustatud kriitikale vastu tulles olen ma ostnud Tartu Mööbliaidalt nägusa, raske puust sambaga, põrandalambi, võimalikult umbes aastast 1955-1965-1965, pealetrükitud tunnusmärgi järgi toodetud kusagil väljaspool toonast "Liitu". - Veel "(b)" osas ma toonitaksin, et minu elamine peab olema TTÜ Eesti Mereakadeemia, või siis Kuningliku Mereväe, stiilis korrektne - kõik olgu kompaktne, soliidne, tööle pühendatud, ilma ülearuliste mugavusteta. - A certain school of opinion in my family finds me embarking on an excessively ascetic lifestyle at Tõravere. To this critique I would, however, respectfully reply (a) that the storeroom-private library-dry lab in "nr. 38" can be made as ascetic as desired, with its occupant becoming as gentrified as necessary, and (b) that the living space which is "nr. 34" could be made more presentable with the mounting of a curtain (if the owner permits it) to comouflage the existing shower cabin and kitchen sink. Under heading "(b)", I would further stress that by way of a response to the partially justified critique from this school of opinion, I have bought from the Tartu Mööbliait ("Furniture Shack") an attractive floorlamp, with heavy wooden column, possibly from the years 1955-1965-1975. Some printing on my purchase indicates that it got manufactured in some jurisdiction outside the erstwhile "Union". - Also under heading "(b)", I would stress that my living arrangements must be correct in the sense of the Estonian Maritime Academy at the Tallinn University of Technology, or again of the Royal Navy: all must be compact, solid, dedicated to work, and stripped of superfluous comforts.
Olen muide tänulik Mereakadeemia lahkele vastuvõtule Luureretke käigus, kusjuures insenerist sugulasele BCDE ja mulle anti juurdepääs ka Mereakadeemia muuseumile. Kes tahab Eesti auväärse merendusega tutvust luua, külastagu Mereakadeemiat, Tallinna Kopli ranna läheduses. Sisenemise hetkel tuleks vist ennast tutvustada esikus asuvale kontorilauale, mille üle seisab kahekeelses kirjas "Valveohvitser/Watch Officer". - Thanks are, incidentally, due to the Estonian Maritime Academy for generous hospitality during the Preliminary Recce Manoeuvre. The hospitality included granting of admission, both to BCDE and to me, to the Academy's own museum. Let those who wish to acquaint themselves with Estonia's honourable seafaring traditions visit the Maritime Academy, in the vicinity of the Kopli shoreline in Tallinn. At the moment of entry, it would perhaps be advisable to introduce oneself to the office desk in the foyer, over which bilingual signage reads "Valveohvitser/Watch Officer".

Ja kes tahab Kuningliku Mereväega tutvuda, see uurigu YouTube'i materjale, kasvõi vana mereseebikat "Warship: Series 1 - Episode 1 - Hot Pursuit". Selle URL-iks minu praeguses, Kanadas asuvas, Interneti nurgas on https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ok3Mpu4CL3Y&t=2890s (YouTube'i tarbijalt "Rhonda Cortez", laadimiskuupäevaga 2017-11-25, kestvusega 1:58:22). - And those wishing to acquaint themselves with the Royal Navy should check out YouTube materials, if only the old naval soap "Warship: Series 1 - Episode 1 - Hot Pursuit". In my present, Canadian, corner of the Internet, the "Warship" URL is https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ok3Mpu4CL3Y&t=2890s (from YouTube user "Rhonda Cortez", in an upload of 2017-11-25, to a length of 1:58:22).

Neid näpunäiteid ma pakuksin veel täahelepanekuga, et iga observatoorium on nii-öelda laev Jumala Mereväes, iga vaatleja nii-öelda oma väike Sir Johan Pitka. - I would offer these tips with the further remark that every observatory is so-to-speak a ship in God's Navy, and every observer so-to-speak his or her own little Sir Johan Pitka. [NOTE ADDED: English-language background on Sir Johan Pitka (1872-1944), as the War-of-Independence founder of the Estonian navy, and additionally as a settlement pioneer in British Columbia, can be had from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Johan_Pitka.]

4. Perekondklikke Meelespäid/ Memoranda on Family Matters

Ma ei taha siin palju kirjutada sugulastest ega hõimlastest, ehkki neil oli rõõmus ja tähtis - kogune keskne? - koht üldises "Luureretkes". Praegu tuleb vaid kirja panna mõned laused poolelijäänud asjadest nooriima põlve juures. - I do not wish to write much here regarding my relations, even though they played a happy and important - even a central? - role in the general Preliminary Recce Manoeuvre. At the moment it is appropriate merely to write out a few sentences, recording unfinished business with the very youngest generation.

(A) Armsa noorpreili "PQRS"-i osas: - Regarding the dear Young Miss "PQRS":

  • Vastastikune Saksa Nimede Pakt ehk VSNP sõlmitud: kui PQRS juhtub vallatu preili olema, on mul õigus talle külge pookida temale ebameeldiv nimi Emilie Charlottenburg Ångströmuppsalagatan von und zu Grafenstein. Teiselt poolt kui mina ise juhtun millegipärast vallatu onu olema tema vastu (see aga oleks vaevalt tõenäone), on temal õigus minu külge pookida analoogselt taunitav nimi Georg Wilhelm Friedrich von und zu Grafenstein. - A Mutual German Naming Pact (MGNP) has now been formalized: should PQRS become a misbehaving Miss, I have the right to burden her with the name (to her offputting) Emilie Charlottenburg Ångströmuppsalagatan von und zu Grafenstein. Reciprocally, if I myself should happen to misbehave as an uncle (but this is scarcely conceivable), she has the right to burden me with the analogously deprecatory name Georg Wilhelm Friedrich von und zu Grafenstein.
  • Faber-Castelli sirkel ja 360-kraadine mall nüüd pidulikult üle antud, kui meie loodava "Instituudi" Tartu haru esimesed instrumendid. - A Faber-Castell compass and a 360-degree protractor have now been ceremoniously handed over, as the first instruments in the founding of our special Institute's Tartu branch.
  • Malli abil juba illustreeritud, kuidas iga lamedale pinnale joonistatud kolmnurga nurkade sisemised kraadisuurused teevad kokku 180. Ees seisab veel selle üldlause tõestus. (Kusjuures, antud suvaline kolmnurk ABC lamedal pinnal, tuleb läbi punkt A-d tõmmata joon paralleelselt BC-küljega, ja siis uurida kolm kõrvutiasuvat nurka, mis on A-kohal.) - Ees seisab veel uurimine - tähtis Mereakadeemia ning Kuningliku Mereväe navigaatoritele, ja abstraktsemal kujul tähtis Einsteini üldrelatiivsusteoorias ning praeguses kosmoloogias - mis juhtub kolmnurga nurkadega, kui kolmnurk on joonistatud ebalamedal pinnal. (Üheks eriti silmatorkavaks ebalamedaks pinnaks, ja erilise tähtsusega merel mandritevahelises navigeerimises, on sfäär. Sealjuures loodaksin teha PQRS-iga katseid oma Ungarist 2017.a. muretsetud Lénart'i sfääriga, kui see sügisel saabub Tõraverre meretranspordil Kanadast. Minu imponeeriv Budapesti sfäär on koguni varustatud sfäärilise geomeetria malli, sfäärilise geomeetria mõõdupulgaga (täpsemalt mõõdurõngaga) ja sfäärilise geomeetria sirkliga. Sfääri ja tema juurdekuuluvaid instrumente saab praegugi uurida saitidelt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/L%C3%A9n%C3%A1rt_sphere ja http://lenartsphere.com/.) - With the help of the protractor, it has been illustrated how every triangle drawn on a plane has internal angles adding up, in degree measure, to 180. This general proposition awaits a proof. (In the proof: given an arbitrary triangle ABC drawn on a plane, pass through point A a line parallel with side BC, and then consider three adjacent angles at A.) - There still lies ahead an investigation - important to navigators in the Estonian Maritime Academy and the Royal Navy, and in an more abstract form important in Einstein's General Relativity and in current cosmology - regarding the angles of a triangle drawn on some surface other than a plane. (One particularly prominent non-planar surface, of special importance in intercontinental navigation, is the sphere. Here I would hope to embark on experiments, with PQRS, involving my Lénart sphere, procured from Hungary in 2017, when this item reaches Tõravere this autumn on the ship from Canada. My imposing Budapest sphere is even equipped with a spherical-geometry compass, a spherical-geometry ruler (or more accurately, with a spherical-geometry measuring-arc), and with a spherical-geometry compass. The sphere and its accompanying instruments can be investigated already at the sites https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/L%C3%A9n%C3%A1rt_sphere and http://lenartsphere.com/.)
(B) Armsa noorhärra "QRST" ning armsa noorpreili "RSTU" osas: - Regarding the dear Jungherr "QRST" and the dear Young Miss "RSTU":
  • Matkakompass, 360-kraadine mall nüüd üle antud, kui meie loodava "Instituudi" Tartust-kaugelasuva haru esimesed instrumendid. - Hiker's compass and 360-degree protractor now handed over, as founding instruments in our "Institute's" remote-from-Tartu branch.
  • Ees seisab veel magneetilise deklinatsiooni uurimine, malli abil, kusjuures võiks taustalugemiseks võtta https://wikivividly.com/lang-et/wiki/Magnetiline_deklinatsioon. - There still awaits an investigation into magnetic declination, with the help of the protractor. Some (Estonian-language) background is supplied by https://wikivividly.com/lang-et/wiki/Magnetiline_deklinatsioon.

APPENDIX: Notes Added for Readers in Anglosaxonia and Russia

It is almost, but not quite, superfluous to add a Tourist-Estonia, or Hollywood-Estonia, remark on music.

To appreciate Estonicity from the inside, one must listen to music.

(a) Helpful here would be one of the patriotic songs. I would select, as poignantly Lutheran-and-Nordic, "Eesti Lipp" ("Estonian Flag"), in the YouTube upload of "AndrusEST" from 2009-08-01, to a length of 0:03:14. In my present corner of the Internet, in Canada, the upload is under the URL https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QqShI-A0yCM.

(b) Also helpful would be some bit of dance. I would here select, as an especially colourful open-air presentation of that perennial cliché which is "Tuljak" (by now absolutely danced to death, I should think, both in Diaspora-Estonia and in Home-Estonia) the YouTube upload of "GErnesaks" from 2013-10-01, to a length of 0:02:57. In my present corner of the Internet, the upload is under the URL https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JK5xUhLL9bs.


It is also useful to step back from Estonia for a moment. We do well to avoid chauvinism, instead recalling how Estonian efforts at preserving and enhancing a specific national culture find parallels within other ethnicities. The Diaspora-Estonia author Arvo Mägi (1913-2004) remarks somewhere on parallels between the histories of Estonia and Ireland. Let the non-Estonian Gentle Reader, then - perhaps from within Anglosaxonia or Russia (these are the two cultural spheres most strongly represented in my recent blogspot server logs) put into YouTube the search term Margaret Gallagher Ireland. Several interesting film clips will come up, one of them entitled "All I've Ever Known: Margaret Gallagher's Story" (from YouTube user "John Callister", on 2015-04-28, to a length of 0:29:26; in my present corner of the Internet in Canada, the upload is under the URL https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lRL9iIN3R8s).

If our Estonian raw-anchovy-with-onion-on-black-ryebread, and wife-carrying-competition, and hot-saun-with-birchbranch-whipping, and endless-Tuljak-dancing (et cetera) culture is found extreme, then let its Irish parallels be pondered instead. Let attention be given to the sense in which Ulster local-history specialist Margaret Gallagher's life is rich and full, not in despite of, but rather in and through, her diligently chosen freedom from modern gadgetry. We in Estonia must ourselves move in Margaret Gallagher's direction, resisting the blandishments of globalism and commerce. Anglosaxonia and Russia will recover their respective ancient spiritual strengths by doing likewise.

Always our questions, whatever our particular given ethnicity, must be: how did our forefathers discharge their duty of care toward their towns and countryside? and: what are now our own duties of restoration and remembrance? 

In my own case, the duties of restoration and remembrance entail personal attention to something already venerable, namely Estonian astronomy, and more generally to the welfare of that venerable Tartu University which educated my mother, my father, and my father's father, and under whose administrative wing Tõravere itself now operates.

Other people, living within other ethnicities, will have other sets of duties.

I will not pause here to remark on the special challenges facing Anglosaxonia, as it struggles with material overabundance, silly "social media", and the UK-USA 2016 undercuttings of normal parliamentary politics. But I will allow myself to remark briefly here that in the specially and distinctively troubling case of Russia, what is required is a return to selected pre-1917 institutions and ways - including, I would respectfully suggest to my current FSB or SVR blogspot surveillance officers, the Old Church Slavonic liturgies and the local-municipality democracy of the zemstvo/земство.

I have previously remarked here on blogspot, but will say this month again, that a way forward for Russia is suggested by the writings - now available also in Russian - of émigrée Ontario-based theologian Ekaterina Fyodorovna Kolyschkine de Hueck Doherty (Екатерина Фёдоровна Колышкина; 1896-1985).

[Siin on praeguse blogspot-i pala lõpp. / This is the end of the current blogspot posting.]